Donate Here

Letters

Guilty Until Proven Innocent: My Experience of Remand

By

Donnie

Donnie writes from a Victorian prison.

Willy Pleasance

As a person that has never been on the wrong side of the law, you may automatically believe that "guilty until proven innocent" is a fact of the justice system. But I have been remanded into custody now since late 2019 – with no opportunity thus far to prove my innocence. So when is my opportunity? At a trial which is still years away? How can I gather evidence to prove my innocence while in custody?

I have been for bail but it was denied on the grounds that the size of the charge is large and can carry a long sentence if convicted, and also the strength of the prosecution's case. But, the major factor was that I did not meet the "Exceptional Circumstances" rule to be granted bail.

My defence would be that my case (drug related) is circumstantial with no direct evidence. There was also no evidence of threat to the community, threat to individuals, no links to organised crime, no links to people with drug related convictions, no drug use or possession, and no criminal history, not even a past visit to a police station. So is all this innocent until proven guilty? Yes, one could make a bail application to the Supreme Court but what if one cannot afford it or you lack the required surety? I'm not eligible for legal aid and I cannot afford the cost of legal defence. So while I wait on remand for my time to prove my innocence, I stand to lose everything I've ever worked for – my business, my family's home, assets, years of my children growing up and finally, my sanity.

I acknowledge that I am the minority and am very thankful that I have a great external support system but being remanded into Victoria's prison system is no different from being convicted. If anything, it is worse.

The mundane tasks that we do to be a part of society and to provide for our families such as paying the bills and mortgage, pets, children, partners all become inaccessible even if your external supports are willing to take on your burden. Not being personally present makes external tasks often impossible. So when does innocent until proven guilty come into play? In my case it hasn't…yet.

Would it then be different if I was a celebrity? Or had high profile connections? Or maybe bags of hidden cash?

Before all this I was a husband, father, brother and son living an ordinary life but now I am "guilty until proven innocent'.

As a person that has never been on the wrong side of the law, you may automatically believe that "guilty until proven innocent" is a fact of the justice system. But I have been remanded into custody now since late 2019 – with no opportunity thus far to prove my innocence. So when is my opportunity? At a trial which is still years away? How can I gather evidence to prove my innocence while in custody?

I have been for bail but it was denied on the grounds that the size of the charge is large and can carry a long sentence if convicted, and also the strength of the prosecution's case. But, the major factor was that I did not meet the "Exceptional Circumstances" rule to be granted bail.

My defence would be that my case (drug related) is circumstantial with no direct evidence. There was also no evidence of threat to the community, threat to individuals, no links to organised crime, no links to people with drug related convictions, no drug use or possession, and no criminal history, not even a past visit to a police station. So is all this innocent until proven guilty? Yes, one could make a bail application to the Supreme Court but what if one cannot afford it or you lack the required surety? I'm not eligible for legal aid and I cannot afford the cost of legal defence. So while I wait on remand for my time to prove my innocence, I stand to lose everything I've ever worked for – my business, my family's home, assets, years of my children growing up and finally, my sanity.

I acknowledge that I am the minority and am very thankful that I have a great external support system but being remanded into Victoria's prison system is no different from being convicted. If anything, it is worse.

The mundane tasks that we do to be a part of society and to provide for our families such as paying the bills and mortgage, pets, children, partners all become inaccessible even if your external supports are willing to take on your burden. Not being personally present makes external tasks often impossible. So when does innocent until proven guilty come into play? In my case it hasn't…yet.

Would it then be different if I was a celebrity? Or had high profile connections? Or maybe bags of hidden cash?

Before all this I was a husband, father, brother and son living an ordinary life but now I am "guilty until proven innocent'.

Topics
This
letter
was originally printed in the
November 2024
edition of About Time.
By Biannca

Just thought I would send in two photos of what I have been up to during my time in prison.

ISSUE NO. 26
1 MIN READ
By Chris

Finding information relating to Commonwealth Parole or people able to provide correct advice has proven challenging since I was sentenced.

ISSUE NO. 26
2 MIN READ
By Aidan

I am writing as I saw my partner’s article and it inspired me. This is probably my millionth time in prison, and time stands still.

ISSUE NO. 26
1 MIN READ
By Adrian

How do we escape the trap of feeling worse rather than better?

ISSUE NO. 26
3 MIN READ

Welcome to About Time

About Time is the national newspaper for Australian prisons and detention facilities

Your browser window currently does not have enough height, or is zoomed in too far to view our website content correctly. Once the window reaches the minimum required height or zoom percentage, the content will display automatically.

Alternatively, you can learn more via the links below.

Donations via GiveNow

Email

Instagram

LinkedIn

Get All the Latest News From About Time in Your Inbox

Be the first to read each edition online and receive two newsletters each month filled with news stories, experiences, creativity and the voices of people in prison around the country.

X

X

You've successfully registered!
Something went wrong when we tried to register your details. Please try again.